Skip to main content

Non-Law Friday: A Lawyer's View of the NFL Catch Rule

There has been an increasing focus over the past few years on the rules and their interpretation in professional sports leagues.  This is particularly the case in the NFL, as anyone who is familiar with Mike Pereira or the phrases “football move” and “survive the ground” well knows.

Sports rules work exactly like statutes:  A deliberative body drafts language that gets codified in a rulebook (in sports) or code (in law).  It falls to the judges or referees to apply that written rule to real-world situations.  Often, it’s not clear from the language of the rule how it ought to be applied to situations that arise in the real world, which forces the adjudicator to rely upon their own interpretation of how the rule is intended to govern the facts presented to them.
The NFL currently has a problem with one of its rules -- the so-called “catch rule.”  Lots of NFL fans disagree with how the rule is being applied by game officials to govern situations that arise during play.  Some of the most infamous officiating controversies of the past few years have resulted from plays that look to fans like clear touchdown catches, but are called incomplete after the inevitable minutes-long interruption for video review.
The rule for what counts as a catch seems simple enough:

ARTICLE 3. COMPLETED OR INTERCEPTED PASS. A player who makes a catch may advance the ball. A forward pass is complete (by the offense) or intercepted (by the defense) if a player, who is inbounds:
(a) secures control of the ball in his hands or arms prior to the ball touching the ground; and

(b) touches the ground inbounds with both feet or with any part of his body other than his hands; and

(c) maintains control of the ball after (a) and (b) have been fulfilled, until he has the ball long enough to clearly become a runner.  A player has the ball long enough to become a runner when, after his second foot is on the ground, he is capable of avoiding or warding off impending contact of an opponent, tucking the ball away, turning up field, or taking additional steps.

So the players has to (1) secure control of the ball, (2) touch the ground inbounds with two feet or another non-hands body part, and (3) maintain control of the ball long enough to clearly become a runner.  (This third requirement is often referred-to in broadcasts using the phrase “football move.”)

            But!  The NFL’s rulemakers have decided that these three requirements aren’t adequate to cover all game situations, and has created sub-rules for six different catch scenarios.   One of these is the infamous “Player Going to the Ground.”  Here’s what the “Going to the Ground” subrule says:

Item 1. Player Going to the Ground. A player is considered to be going to the ground if he does not remain upright long enough to demonstrate that he is clearly a runner.  If a player goes to the ground in the act of catching a pass (with or without contact by an opponent), he must maintain control of the ball until after his initial contact with the ground, whether in the field of play or the end zone.  If he loses control of the ball, and the ball touches the ground before he regains control, the pass is incomplete. If he regains control prior to the ball touching the ground, the pass is complete.

As calls on the field have illustrated, there is a lot open to interpretation here.  Most obviously, how long can the “initial contact with the ground” last?  Is it the instant a player first touches the ground, or is it through three complete log rolls?  Again, lots of calls have suggested that officials think it is closer to the latter — we have all seen calls where the official calls a pass incomplete if the ball touches the ground any time before the player on the ground stops moving — but the absence of guidance from the rule forces officials to create their own standard.

The NFL is widely expected to simplify the “catch rule” this offseason in an effort to address some of these problems.  It may even do away with the subrule for “Going to the Ground.”

Two options that might work are:

(1)  Simply strike the “Going to the Ground” rule, so that a ball is a catch the moment a player has control and two feet (or a body part) down.  The consequence of this change would be that many plays currently called incomplete would become fumbles.  But fumbles are exciting, so maybe that’s a feature rather than a bug.

      (2)  Keep the “Going to the Ground” rule, but add that if the player is extending the ball forward as he goes to the ground, that’s the same as making a football move, thereby making inapplicable the requirement to “survive the ground.”  This would make the Jesse James play for the Steelers against the Patriots this past December a touchdown.

My bet is that the NFL will adopt something like #2, possibly limiting the exception to when the player is extending the ball in an effort to cross the goal line.  But as I have suggested, the devil is always in the drafting.  Better hire some lawyers or legislative drafters to take a look at this thing before it goes live.


- Eric

--
Eric Penley, Esq.  /  Preti Flaherty LLP  /  epenley@preti.com  /  (617) 226-3800

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Reaction to the Stone Brewing Lawsuit against MillerCoors

Reaction to the Stone Brewing Trademark Lawsuit against MillerCoors By Eric G. Penley, Esq. (617) 226-3854 Preti Flaherty Beliveau & Pachios LLP February 14, 2017 Stone Brewing Company’s lawsuit against MillerCoors, which was filed in federal court in Southern California on February 12th, has attracted attention in the craft beer world on the internet and social media.  Stone is one of the highest-profile craft brewers, in large part because it has a deserved reputation as a pioneer of the ultra-popular West Coast IPA style.  (Disclosure:  I have one or two bottles of Stone beer in my fridge at home as I write this.)  Stone’s lawsuit makes claims against MillerCoors, including a trademark infringement claim, relating to the alleged use of the “Stone” trademark in ads and packing for Keystone beers. I read the Complaint and have a few thoughts.  At the outset, remember that a Complaint is a set of allegations that the plaintiff has ...