There has been an increasing focus over the past few years on the rules and their interpretation in professional sports leagues. This is particularly the case in the NFL, as anyone who is familiar with Mike Pereira or the phrases “football move” and “survive the ground” well knows . Sports rules work exactly like statutes: A deliberative body drafts language that gets codified in a rulebook (in sports) or code (in law). It falls to the judges or referees to apply that written rule to real-world situations. Often, it’s not clear from the language of the rule how it ought to be applied to situations that arise in the real world, which forces the adjudicator to rely upon their own interpretation of how the rule is intended to govern the facts presented to them. The NFL currently has a problem with one of its rules -- the so-called “catch rule.” Lots of NFL fans disagree with how the rule is being applied by game officials to govern situations th...
Reaction to the Stone Brewing Trademark Lawsuit against MillerCoors By Eric G. Penley, Esq. (617) 226-3854 Preti Flaherty Beliveau & Pachios LLP February 14, 2017 Stone Brewing Company’s lawsuit against MillerCoors, which was filed in federal court in Southern California on February 12th, has attracted attention in the craft beer world on the internet and social media. Stone is one of the highest-profile craft brewers, in large part because it has a deserved reputation as a pioneer of the ultra-popular West Coast IPA style. (Disclosure: I have one or two bottles of Stone beer in my fridge at home as I write this.) Stone’s lawsuit makes claims against MillerCoors, including a trademark infringement claim, relating to the alleged use of the “Stone” trademark in ads and packing for Keystone beers. I read the Complaint and have a few thoughts. At the outset, remember that a Complaint is a set of allegations that the plaintiff has ...