Reaction to the Stone Brewing Trademark Lawsuit against MillerCoors
By Eric G. Penley,
Esq.
(617) 226-3854
Preti Flaherty
Beliveau & Pachios LLP
February 14, 2017
Stone Brewing Company’s lawsuit
against MillerCoors, which was filed in federal court in Southern California on
February 12th, has attracted attention in the craft beer world on the
internet and social media. Stone is one
of the highest-profile craft brewers, in large part because it has a deserved
reputation as a pioneer of the ultra-popular West Coast IPA style. (Disclosure: I have one or two bottles of Stone beer in my
fridge at home as I write this.) Stone’s
lawsuit makes claims against MillerCoors, including a trademark infringement
claim, relating to the alleged use of the “Stone” trademark in ads and packing
for Keystone beers.
I read the Complaint and have a
few thoughts. At the outset, remember
that a Complaint is a set of allegations that the plaintiff has a basis in fact
to believe it can prove. If the defendant
believes that even assuming the truth of the factual allegations, a complaint does
not meet the legal standard(s) for the claims made by the plaintiff, it can argue
to the judge that the claims should be dismissed.
1)
The Complaint is both as a marketing
play and a lawsuit. It was written for
public consumption; not just for the court.
For example, within the first couple of paragraphs of factual
allegations, the Complaint refers to the “awesome reputation of Stone’s craft
brews” and states that Stone “has always stood for a philosophy and approach
that belies the watered-down orthodoxy of ‘Big Beer’ companies and their fizzy
yellow offerings.” This “craft beer vs.
big beer” framing is a key part of Stone’s marketing strategy. Another example of this appears in paragraph 4
of the Complaint, which includes the irrelevant allegation that Stone’s
cofounder Greg Koch recently “publicly announced that the Gargoyle will never sell
out.” If the Complaint were not intended
in part as a marketing tool, it would not include these kinds of characterizations
and allegations, which add nothing to the lawsuit itself and consequently tend
to be looked upon by experienced lawyers and judges as sophomoric and
unnecessary.
2)
The key allegations in the Complaint relate to
MillerCoors’ alleged rebranding of its Keystone brand beers to emphasize the word
“‘Stone.” MillerCoors has lately used
marketing that seeks to capitalize on “Stones” as a well-known nickname for Keystone
cans (as in, “if you’re going through the kitchen, why don’t you bring back a
couple of ‘Stones?”) Stone Brewing registered
the “Stone” trademark for beers and ales with the U.S. Patent and Trademark
Office on June 23, 1998, which means that it is entitled to sole use of the “Stone”
mark for beer and ale marketing.
3)
The Complaint includes interesting visuals
showing the way in which the new Keystone branding appears on cans and boxes in
stores and the way in which the word “Stone” is emphasized in social media
posts and ads:
4)
To prevail on its claim, Stone Brewing would
have to prove that there is a “likelihood of confusion” between its products
and any MillerCoors products bearing the “Stone” mark. This test asks whether the alleged infringer’s
use of the mark is “likely to cause confusion or to cause mistake, or to
deceive as to the affiliation, connection, or association” of the two
products. 11 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1). The federal appeals court whose law governs
the case, the Ninth Circuit, has developed a multifactor test for “likelihood
of confusion,” including:
·
Strength of the mark (how strongly the mark
is associated with the specific product);
·
Proximity of the goods (whether the two goods are
related);
·
Similarity of the marks;
·
Evidence of actual confusion by customers;
·
Marketing channels used (e.g., are the products sold in the same store);
·
Type of goods and the degree of care likely to
be exercised by the purchaser;
·
Defendant’s intent in selecting the mark; and
·
Likelihood of expansion of the product lines (to
compete with one another)
Assuming that Stone’s trademark infringement claim is strong enough to overcome a possible motion to dismiss for legal insufficiency of the allegations, these factors are where the case will be fought. I have some preliminary views about how some of the factors above may shake out, but this is where the opposing lawyers will have to earn their money by developing strong evidence to support their client’s position.
5)
If Stone Brewing is able to prove trademark infringement
or one of its other claims, it is unclear what amount of damages it
could prove. One way to assess whether
Stone looks at this as a strong trademark case that it could take through trial
versus a mere marketing opportunity is to see how long the case goes without
settling — will Stone go to the mattresses, or instead reach an agreed
resolution with MillerCoors after a period of weeks or months that involves
some minor changes to Keystone packaging or ads? The latter could allow Stone to declare a win
against (in its language) the “watered-down orthodoxy of ‘Big Beer’” for a
modest litigation cost.
Comments
Post a Comment